The debate over the Confederate flag flying over the
statehouse is no longer a debate about the flag, Lexington County’s state
legislators say.
Both state senator Joe Wilson and state legislator Jake
Knotts believe the real battle now is one for political power.
Wilson said taking the flag down “would give the appearance
of capitulation to the national NAACP.’’ Knotts beleives the credibility of the
state legislature is at stake now over the issue of the flag.
The national NAACP has called for a boycott of the state,
and has demanded the flag come down. Other groups have also joined the move to
bring the flag down.
Knotts said he had been willing to listen and perhaps
negotiate, but he so objects to strong arm tactics that he said “there is
nothing to negotiate now.’’
Both representatives dislike the idea of a national
organization using a boycott to force the legislature to act.
“Laws should be passed on their merit ... it is just a
different issue now,’’ Knotts said.
Even apart from the flag issue, Knotts believes it is wrong
for a national organization to try to coerce a state legislative body do
something.
“If we were to give in to the national NAACP, then what
would stop the AFL-CIO from demanding that we change right to work laws in
South Carolina?’’ Knotts said.
Wilson said both houses voted in 1995 to keep the flag
flying in the face of a threat posed by a lawsuit to take it down.
“That move was designed to bypass the legislative process.
But at that time we had more mutual respect. The vote was unanimous then. Now
it is just an attack on our heritage,’’ Wilson said.
Wilson said the boycott advocated by the NAACP is not about
the flag, but is “an attempt to undo and defame our confederate heritage. The
only negotiation they want to do is to take it down,’’ he said.
Other groups around the state have joined the effort to
lower the flag. Last week State Chamber of Commerce President Paula Bethea
threatened to withdraw financial support from the Republican party unless they
change their position on the flag.
The remarks were made to a committee of the Republican
Caucus that Knotts is on, and it angered him.
“I couldn’t believe it. We were there to listen to their
reasons for wanting the flag to come down. It is stupid on their part to think
they could buy my vote. My vote is not for sale. Even my wife can’t buy my
vote,’’ Knotts said.
The representative said he would vote the way his
constituents wanted him to vote, and they favor keeping the flag flying.
Knotts added that if the legislature gave in to the demands
to lower the flag, such a move would have wide ranging effects.
“If we did take the flag down that would not mean it was
over. What they want is to wipe out every memory of the heritage of the
Confederacy,’’ Knotts said.
Knotts said the Republican Caucus is not willing to come to
the table and discuss the matter as long as the boycott remains in effect.
Wilson also had harsh words for the boycott, and said people
need to have mutual respect and honesty for negotiations to happen. He said he
did not know if the Senate would deal with the issue in the next session of the
General Assembly which starts in January.
He said in an environment of mutual respect, negotiations
could happen, but recent developments have impaired that respect. “I would hope
we could get back to that era of mutual respect in the upcoming session. I will
continue to have respect for them, (flag opponents) and I hope they will for
us,’’ Wilson said.
Lexington County’s only Democrat representative, Nikki
Setzler, said he supports the flag, but said he really didn’t know if the
legislature would take up the issue in the next session.
Wilson said the issue has been a diversion from more
important issue such as education.
“This is an attack on heritage. It is also about money and
attracting attention on a nationwide level for the NAACP. It is a diversion
from more important issues,’’ Wilson said.
The flag also flies inside the chambers of the state house and senate, and there has been some talk of taking the flag down there as well, Wilson said.